Iraq, Vietnam, and Korea

 

By Richard Norman

 

President Bush received a fair amount of flak (though no more than usual) this week when he compared the potential consequences of withdrawing from Iraq to those of leaving Vietnam, saying, "One unmistakable legacy of Vietnam is that the price of America’s withdrawal was paid by millions of innocent citizens, whose agonies would add to our vocabulary new terms like ‘boat people,’ ‘re-education camps’ and ‘killing fields’." After years of the most abysmal communication, pathetic rhetoric, and plain historical ignorance, the U.S. government is finally making a strong argument in defence of its Iraq policy. Continue reading

Power of Nightmares

Scream.jpg 

 

By Otto Spijkers

The Power of Nightmares (BBC documentary) "explores how the idea that we are threatened by a hidden and organised terrorist network is an illusion. It is a myth that has spread unquestioned through politics, the security services and the international media. At the heart of the story are two groups: the American neo-conservatives and the radical Islamists. Both were idealists who were born out of the failure of the liberal dream to build a better world" (that’s taken from the BBC website). I guess most people know this documentary already (it is three years old), but those who do not: you can watch the documentary on Google video. See below for links. Continue reading

Hammarskjold’s grave and legacy (Part IV: death)

 

By Otto Spijkers

 

When dag died.jpg18 September 1961, Hammarskjold died in a mysterious plane crash as he entered the skies of what was then Northern Rhodesia, now Zambia. The Secretary-General of the United Nations was due to meet rebel leader Moise Tshombe and negotiate a truce with him in the civil war between the Katanga secessionist movement of Tshombe and the Congolese central government. There are quite a lot of theories relating to his death (see e.g. here, here, and here), but many insiders, including Brian Urquhart, believe it was just an accident. In a biography of Hammarskjold written by Urquhart, the story ends as follows:

Only Harold Julien [ONUC chief of security] was alive when the search party finally reached the wreckage on the following afternoon, and he died of burns five days later. Hammarskjold was thrown clear of the wreckage and, alone among the victims, was not burned at all. Although the post-mortem showed that he had probably lived for a short time after the crash, his injuries – a severely fractured spine, several broken ribs, a broken breastbone, a broken thigh, and severe internal hemorrhaging – were certainly fatal. He was lying on his back near a small shrub which had escaped the fire, his face extraordinarily peaceful, a hand clutching a tuft of grass. (Hammarskjold, p. 589.)

Continue reading

Hammarskjold’s grave and legacy (Part III: Article 99 of the UN Charter)

hammarskjold.jpg 

By Otto Spijkers

 

Article 99 is by far the most important article in the short list of articles in the UN Charter assigning functions to the Secretary-General (articles 97-100). Article 99 explicitly gives the SG important political power. When article 98 still assigns mainly administrative functions to the SG, be it with some political ‘side effects’, article 99 is purely political. SG Dag Hammarskjold (see picture) said that ‘[i]t is article 99 more than any other [article] which was considered by the drafters of the Charter to have transformed the Secretary-General from a purely administrative official to one with an explicit political responsibility’ (Source: p. 335 of Foote, Servant of Peace: A Selection of the Speeches and Statements of Dag Hammarskjold. Harper & Row Publishers, New York, 1962.). Continue reading

Hammarskjold’s grave and legacy (Part II: peacekeeping)

untitled.JPG 

By Otto Spijkers

 

The second Secretary-General in UN history, the Swede Dag Hammarskjold, explored the three bedrock principles of traditional peacekeeping in a report he wrote for the United Nations Emergency Force (UNEF) stationed in Egypt between November 1957 and June 1967 (this picture and the picture below shows UNEF peacekeepers on duty). This is the report. Continue reading

Hammarskjold’s grave and legacy (Part I: clash with Khrushchev)

Hammarskjold's grave in Uppsala.jpg 

By Otto Spijkers

 

Last week, I spent a few days in Stockholm and surroundings. One thing I did was visit the grave of one of UN’s big heroes: the second Secretary-General of the United Nations, Dag Hammarskjold (on the picture you see me at his grave in Uppsala, a small town close to Stockholm where Hammarskjold spent his student days). This visit inspired me to write a few posts about the illustrious Swede. I will start with a short description of the famous clash between him and Nikita Khrushchev, Chairman of the Council of Ministers of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. The clash was about the Congo peacekeeping operation (ONUC), which was essentially run by the Secretary-General (at least according to Khrushchev). In following posts, I will write about peacekeeping (Post II) and Article 99 of the UN Charter (Post III). I will also write about his mysterious death (Post IV). Continue reading

The politics of withdrawing from Iraq

iraq_road.jpg 

By Richard Norman

 

Michael Ignatieff, currently the deputy leader of the Liberal party of Canada, reconsiders his initial position on the war in Iraq in this weekend’s New York Times Magazine:

Having left an academic post at Harvard in 2005 and returned home to Canada to enter political life, I keep revisiting the Iraq debacle, trying to understand exactly how the judgments I now have to make in the political arena need to improve on the ones I used to offer from the sidelines. I’ve learned that acquiring good judgment in politics starts with knowing when to admit your mistakes.

Continue reading

Sarkozy and Libya

sg.jpg 

By Richard Norman

 

There was a time when the Bush Administration held up Libyan WMD concessions as an example of a (lonely) diplomatic triumph, and Tony Blair visited Muammar Gaddafi in Tripoli to hail a "new relationship." For a time, increased economic and political ties followed. But when five Bulgarian nurses and a Palestinian doctor, speciously accused of deliberately infecting children with HIV at a hospital in Benghazi, were sentenced to death by Libya’s Supreme Court, Col. Gaddafi’s regime again became isolated. Continue reading

Legal Capital of the World gets yet another Tribunal

Legal Capital.jpg 

By Otto Spijkers

 

The Hague presents itself as the city of Peace, justice and Security. With the proliferation of international courts and tribunals in The Hague, it seems almost impossible to keep up with all the legal developments (or lack thereof: yesterday we celebrated the 12th anniversary of the indictment against Mladi? and Karad?i?, both still at large). Fortunately, there’s the Hague Justice Portal, which keeps us up to date on all the developments. One of these developments is the acquirement of a new criminal tribunal: the Hariri Tribunal. Continue reading

The Philosophies of Gordon Brown

 

By Richard Norman

 

brownL.jpgA few interesting things about Gordon Brown today (actually from a few weeks ago). This series of articles in Prospect Magazine about Brown as intellectual are worth looking at for those interested in his background and philosophical evolution over the years. There’s something for both people who like him and dislike him. Some quotes after the jump. Continue reading